DID And The Survivor’s Cynic

DID And The Survivor’s Cynic-Thursday, August 31, 2006-6:22AM EST

The terms defined below are so that readers will understand what context I’m using them in for this entry.

  • System- what a group of alters is called
  • Alter- a personality
  • Outsiders- any person that is not a member of Morton’s Pride. Any person not part of a specific group of alter personalities is an outsider. I’m an outsider to another DID’s group of personalities. Those not in our system are outsiders those inside our system are insiders.
  • Survivor- in this entry a survivor is referring to someone who lived through abuse as a child. We all know that the word survivor encompasses a larger group of people but in this entry I’m specifically talking about survivors of child abuse.
  • Trigger warnings- a warning bloggers put up at the top of an entry so that readers will know that what they have to say may be upsetting to some.

While I was going to write a whole soapbox entry about why I object to trigger warnings on blog entries and how I think survivors can be some of the cruelest people around I’ve decided to simply let that aspect go and address something different. Hey, ya know, educate the ignorant don’t slap them repeatedly because you may do more brain damage and they’ll remain stupid forever. You can quote me on that if you’d like. Anyway, I decided to write about the age groups that write on my journal and the common misconceptions surrounding how certain age groups should sound when writing.

Many outsiders believe that if an alter is age 3 they wouldn’t write on a journal because 3 year olds don’t write. Many outsiders believe that if a teenager writes they will write in such a way that identifies them as a teenager. When it comes to members of Morton’s Pride we do not fall into some preconceived idea of how we should write. As I understand it, most DID’s do not fall into a preconceived idea though they are often expected to. Although we have many similarities we have a lot more differences because our abuse was different. Our environment, our culture, economic standing, the education of our family and other factors played a part in our up bringing, not just the abuse. There are few times when a blanket idea fits every situation. There are more times though when doubt is cast because someone doesn’t fit under your version of the blanket. That is just wrong.

When survivors don’t fit into a particular mold other survivors say that person is lying about having DID. They’re a fake. I’ve seen it too many times. As a matter of fact I was reading a blog where that blogger discredited a survivor based on her own preconceived ideas of how that person’s alters should have acted because of how old that alter is. It’s wrong to say this or that person doesn’t have DID when you do not know that person and have never sat fact to face with them. Not even the most skilled professional can tell from one blog entry that a person does or does not have DID. That one particular doubting blogger did more harm than good for survivors with DID because instead of support she cast doubt and may have even given other survivors more reason to not speak up about what happened to them. That kind of undermining is what keeps survivors at war with each other. One would think we’d flock together but often we work against each other, sometimes in subtle ways but other times by out right flagrant means.

When it comes to blogging we in Morton’s Pride are given the freedom to say what we want, how we want. The main goal for Morton’s Pride is to work together and not undermine each other. When “I” write an entry signed with a different name than Austin I worry that people will think I’m faking. If the reader knows the alter writing is young but the entry has an advanced tone then I worry that people will think that I’m faking. My concern is substantiated when I read blogs like one that has recently brought controversial attention to itself.

Keeping with my goal of teaching and not just continuing conflict I’d like to explain how it is that my littles write on this blog. When a very little person has something to say they’ll have a big person type it out for them like dictation. It is very much like how an adult helps a small child write a letter to their grandparents or to some dear person like that. The same kind of assistance applies with inside littles. We help them write and we sign their name. Does it make what is said any less authentic because a bigger person typed their words out for them? Nope. It means our system works well enough together and sees the worth in each of us and is willing to support that worth by making sure even the smallest voice is heard. When it comes to our blog it’s all about the healing of Morton’s Pride but often our words bring us stress because we know that there will be someone who is ready to question and tear down for no other reason than that they have a lot of inner anger they haven’t dealt with. For this reason, when a younger person has written we close off the comments. If a younger alter wants to write we will not subject them to the possibility of rejection or name calling. When a more fragile alter has written we turn off the comment option so that they can write without worrying that someone will try and tear them down. The thing is, we blog on the net for certain reasons but when there is a greater chance for criticism and cruelty we do our best to block it. We will keep writing and we will allow every single member to write but we’ll also do our best to make sure that the writer doesn’t have bricks thrown their way.

As a whole we do not see ourselves as fragile but there are certain areas that we struggle with, like the need to be believed. As a whole we do not see ourselves as a target for criticism but we know there are certain people surfing the net just trying to find something to argue about or to shoot down. I’ve seen it happen too many times. We know that such a person will come to this blog from time to time and we know we will get comments about how ungrateful we are or how we are making this all up. We’ll get combative comments when the comment option is open. It’s happened in the past and it’ll happen again. It is my hope that I’ll always remember their issues fuel their doubt and their need to tear down. I hope I will remember that our goal has not changed simply because a reader can’t find their personal path to recovery. And I hope that we can always encourage and support our young ones to speak when they feel the need to speak and to use the words they feel they need to use. Silence is the best way to keep abuse thriving. Morton’s Pride intends to live out loud.

Me

7 Responses to “DID And The Survivor’s Cynic”


  1. 1 Fallen Angels

    I agree with evrything you have said. We don’t close off comments on little ones posts though…so far that has been okay but I know there is potential for problems. If a problem does arise, we have that option open. The blog you referred to, I cam across in a round about way and I have not returned. I have also not returned to the blog that had it linked in “great links”. I can’t associate with people who are so black and white in their thinking. There is no such thing as an expert in DID…not even professionals in my opinion. Every system is different, every alter is different, etc. How can one claim to be an expert when there are always differences? I am not an expert on our system…let alone anyone (or everyone) elses!

    Warrier

    PS…I would like to hear your thoughts on trigger warnings. We use them occasionally and we appreciate them when others use them, so I would like to hear an opposing view.

  2. 2 beautifuldreamer

    Thank you, Austin, for clarifying what has been a troublesome area for me (and I’m sure for a lot of multiples.) I do have one alter who writes according to her age, but mostly my parts work together, as yours do, to help the younger one express themselves so as to make their words readable to others. Because my younger parts also need to express themselves, it makes sense to have the older ones help them towards their goal of communicating their auntentic selves.

    I too have struggled with this, wondering at times if people will doubt the validity of a passage simply because it isn’t couched in “littles” vernacular. I agree too that there are many surfing the net who are just looking for someone to pounce on, in an effort to discredit them. I don’t know either why among those of us who have been the most wounded, some seem to feel the need to attack and perpetuate cruelty.

    Blogs like yours are making a difference, and the reason is because you speak the unflinching truth.

  3. 3 TheGodfather

    Some things never change like some people’s need to feel superior to others. So they become experts in some special area - they may be affected of it or not - and they try to exterminate all those they consider to be “competitors”. Some of them may suffer but don’t seek for help or don’t want others to suffer. They want all the pain for themselves and so demand all the attention and compassion from others. Some don’teven think they were experts on something though they aren’t - some even consider themselves to be experts on issues you can’t be an expert in cause it’s much too wide, deep and complicated. Like in your expample with DID - judging from a blog entry which is incredibly ridiculous. Others think they could judge others by there last-/ or forename or whatever. There are unlimited possibilities.
    If they try to insult you by saying unsubstantial things, try to ignore them cause you wouldn’t worry about monkeys laughing and pointing at you also.

  4. 4 Mysti

    Thank you for sharing this. It helps truthfully to understand. I myself am always so afraid I might say something wrong that sometimes I choose not to comment. I would never want to be the cause of doing harm of damage to any of you.

    Hugs.

  5. 5 John W

    this blog as well as it’s comments above are so very good. unless little keepers are writing to another little they usually ask me or older keepers to type as they “dictate”. Keepers recently had a comment from someone who was evidently a lot younger than we knew and had we known we would have responded differently. so the age recognition can definitely be a factor in how any of us reply

    really a great post!

    john and keepers

  6. 6 Pilgrim

    A great big “AMEN!!!” to everything you wrote.

  7. 7 WordofAdvice

    Is it possible for someone to have an alter within their system, who dislikes them(main personality), and tries to sabatoge or hurt the main personality similar to the way an abuser may have done in the past?

Leave a Reply